NSW axe murder was spontaneous, judge told

Follow us on Google News:

An elderly divorcee acted spontaneously when he ran down his ex-wife's new partner before chopping his head with an axe, a judge has been told.

Thanh Tran had not been sitting outside her Sydney residence all afternoon or evening, but must have only been there for a few minutes when he saw his victim outside the house, his barrister said.

Janet Manuell SC was making submissions in the NSW Supreme Court on Friday at the sentence hearing of 79-year-old Tran.

He had denied murdering 59-year-old Pok Min Fah on March 14, 2019, but a jury in October found him guilty of the charge.

Tran, who had no criminal history, didn't deny repeatedly striking him with the axe after hitting him with his car.

But he had argued his judgment was substantially impaired due to a loss of control caused by trauma from his lived experience of Cambodian dictator Pol Pot's regime.

Psychiatrists testified he suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder and depression, but experts differed on whether his impairment was substantial.

Married for more than three decades, the couple had a strained relationship and were in effect separated, with his wife sharing their daughter's bedroom for the last 15 years they had together.

Ms Manuell on Friday said CCTV captured Tran's coming and going to the Mekong Club before the attack, not sitting outside his ex-wife's residence in Cabramatta West.

He must have been there for only a few minutes before he saw Mr Fah outside carrying a ladder, which Tran believed belonged to him.

This may have triggered the spontaneous attack as he obviously thought Mr Fah was responsible for breaking up his family life.

Justice Robert Button said the presence of the axe in the boot of Tran's car was troubling, but Ms Manuell said it was not a new axe.

"Clearly it was an axe that was in his possession for some time," she said.

The presence of binoculars in his car could be explained by his hoping to glimpse his children, being pre-occupied with having contact with them despite their unwillingness.

Prosecutor Katharine Jeffreys accepted there was an element of opportunism involved in the attack and Tran had responded to seeing Mr Fah.

"But I would suggest you would reject complete spontaneity," she told the judge, referring to the presence of the binoculars and the axe.

She said Tran's explanation of having the axe for self-defence only was first suggested by him in cross-examination during the trial.

"I submit he had an intent to kill at least when using the axe and from at least the time he started the car and drove it at the deceased."

The judge referred to the absence of evidence indicating remorse.

No victim impact statements were presented to the court.

Justice Button noted that some people who loved and honoured the memory of a deceased person felt a trial barely mentioned them.

"I think I should assure anyone that the deceased is by no means forgotten and indeed his violent death is the whole reason for the trial and proceedings."

He will sentence Tran on December 9.


The content, including but not limited to any articles, news, quotes, information, data, text, reports, ratings, opinions, images, photos, graphics, graphs, charts, animations and video (Content) is a service of Kalkine Media Pty Ltd (Kalkine Media, we or us), ACN 629 651 672 and is available for personal and non-commercial use only. The principal purpose of the Content is to educate and inform. The Content does not contain or imply any recommendation or opinion intended to influence your financial decisions and must not be relied upon by you as such. Some of the Content on this website may be sponsored/non-sponsored, as applicable, but is NOT a solicitation or recommendation to buy, sell or hold the stocks of the company(s) or engage in any investment activity under discussion. Kalkine Media is neither licensed nor qualified to provide investment advice through this platform. Users should make their own enquiries about any investments and Kalkine Media strongly suggests the users to seek advice from a financial adviser, stockbroker or other professional (including taxation and legal advice), as necessary. Kalkine Media hereby disclaims any and all the liabilities to any user for any direct, indirect, implied, punitive, special, incidental or other consequential damages arising from any use of the Content on this website, which is provided without warranties. The views expressed in the Content by the guests, if any, are their own and do not necessarily represent the views or opinions of Kalkine Media. Some of the images/music that may be used on this website are copyright to their respective owner(s). Kalkine Media does not claim ownership of any of the pictures displayed/music used on this website unless stated otherwise. The images/music that may be used on this website are taken from various sources on the internet, including paid subscriptions or are believed to be in public domain. We have used reasonable efforts to accredit the source wherever it was indicated as or found to be necessary.

Featured Articles

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. OK