AUS
NZ
UK
CA
USA
FRA
GER
ESP
ITA
NLD
PRT
SWE
GRC
IND
POL
BRA
ZAF
RUS
CHN
UAE
Highlights
- A UK court rejects a case to recover a hard drive containing £600 million in Bitcoin.
- Legal, environmental, and ownership challenges hinder the case's progress.
- IT specialist James Howells plans to appeal the decision.
A decade-long pursuit to recover £600 million worth of Bitcoin from a landfill in Newport has faced a major legal setback. A UK High Court dismissed James Howells's case to search for a hard drive containing the fortune, ruling it lacked realistic prospects for success.
The hard drive, accidentally discarded in 2013, holds access to approximately 8,000 Bitcoins and has become a subject of global intrigue. Howells, an IT specialist, approached Newport City Council multiple times over the years, offering various solutions and even a share of the funds in exchange for excavation rights. However, legal, environmental, and ownership hurdles stood firmly in his way.
The Court’s Decision
The High Court’s decision, delivered by Judge Keyser KC, cited several reasons for rejecting Howells's claim. Firstly, the court agreed with Newport City Council's argument that the hard drive, upon entering the landfill, legally became the council's property. Secondly, the environmental implications of excavation strengthened the council’s refusal. Judge Keyser added, “The claim would have no realistic prospect of succeeding if it went to trial.”
A Costly Misstep
The saga began during an office cleanup in 2013 when Howells’s hard drive was mistakenly discarded along with other items. The device, believed to contain a fortune in Bitcoin, was inadvertently thrown away in a bag headed to the landfill. Realizing the error, Howells embarked on a lengthy legal journey that included detailed proposals for targeted excavation and professional management to mitigate environmental impact.
Howells’s lawyer, Dean Armstrong KC, argued that modern excavation technology could enable a precise and safe recovery effort. Yet, the council maintained its stance, represented by James Goudie KC, pointing to strict environmental regulations and the ownership transfer of discarded items.
What Lies Ahead
Despite the loss, Howells has not given up. Expressing frustration, he stated that the court's decision deprived him of the chance to present his case fully. Howells also remains optimistic about the Bitcoin’s future value, suggesting it could rise significantly.
While the recent ruling is a blow, Howells is exploring higher judicial avenues, including potentially taking the case to the Supreme Court. As the value of Bitcoin (BTC:USD) fluctuates, his legal efforts remain closely watched by cryptocurrency enthusiasts worldwide.
This case highlights the complex intersection of cryptocurrency, environmental laws, and property ownership, serving as a cautionary tale for digital asset holders.
