AUS
NZ
UK
CA
USA
IND
Highlights
- CBA trades at a significant premium to sector PE ratios
- Dividend models suggest a lower fair value than current price
- Broader market trends and strategy remain key considerations
Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX:CBA) remains one of the most closely watched companies on the Australian Securities Exchange. As the country's largest listed bank by market capitalisation, its performance plays a significant role in shaping the overall direction of the S&P/ASX200 index. But can CBA outperform the broader S&P/ASX200 in 2025?
Valuation methods can help understand where the CBA share price stands today and how it compares to peers. Two commonly used methods include the Price-to-Earnings (PE) ratio and the Dividend Discount Model (DDM).
Starting with the PE ratio, which compares a company's share price to its earnings per share, CBA currently trades on a PE multiple of around 30.7x based on FY24 earnings of $5.63 per share and a share price of $173.09. This is significantly higher than the average PE for the banking sector, which hovers around 18x. Using this average as a benchmark, a sector-adjusted valuation would suggest a CBA share price closer to $103.21.
Beyond PE ratios, a more tailored method for valuing bank stocks is the Dividend Discount Model. This model calculates a fair price for a share based on future expected dividend payments, adjusted for risk and growth assumptions. CBA paid $4.65 in dividends last year, and applying a blended growth rate with a discount rate ranging from 6% to 11% results in an average valuation of around $98.33. When using an adjusted dividend of $4.76, the model yields $100.66. Incorporating franking credits and using a gross dividend forecast of $6.80 pushes the valuation up to $143.80, still below the current trading price.
These models show that while CBA is considered one of the more premium-priced ASX dividend stocks, its current valuation may be factoring in more than just its dividend outlook—perhaps confidence in its strong brand, digital banking leadership, and capital strength.
However, for those analysing the stock further, it’s worth considering the macroeconomic backdrop, including interest rate movements, housing trends, and consumer confidence. In addition, CBA’s strategic direction—whether focused on lending growth or expanding fee-based services—could also shape its future earnings.
Lastly, company culture and leadership effectiveness remain important. While CBA is highly regarded, no institution is flawless, and governance factors can also influence long-term performance.
With CBA trading well above several valuation models, the coming year will be a true test of whether this premium can be sustained against the broader ASX200 index.
